Courts cannot issue direction to state govt to provide quota to any class: SC

25-01-2022 Tue 23:22 IST | IANS | National
Courts cannot issue direction to state govt to provide quota to any class: SC

New Delhi, Jan 25:  The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that a court cannot issue directions to a state government to provide reservation for any class of citizens.

A bench of Justices M.R. Shah and B.V. Nagarathna said: "No mandamus can be issued by the court directing the state government to provide for reservation."

It emphasised that the power lies with the state government to make a provision but, at the same time, courts cannot issue any mandamus to the state to necessarily make such a provision.

The top court made these observations while quashing a high court order to reserve three per cent seats under sports quota in government medical and dental colleges in Punjab.

Citing previous judgments in the matter, the bench observed as far as the provisions for reservation in matters of promotion to any class or classes of post is concerned, such a provision can be made in favour of SC/ST category employees if, in the opinion of the state, they are not adequately represented in services under the state.

"It is observed that therefore power lies with the state to make a provision but, at the same time, Courts cannot issue any mandamus to the state to necessarily make such a provision," it said.

Citing a recent judgment, the top court observed that even no writ of mandamus can be issued directing the state to collect quantifiable data to justify their action not to provide for reservation.

"It was observed that even if the under-representation of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in public services is brought to the notice of the court, no mandamus can be issued by the court to the state government to provide for reservation," noted the bench.

The apex court set aside the August, 2019 order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which had directed the state government to provide sports quota of three per cent in government medical and dental colleges instead of one per cent.

"The High Court has exceeded its jurisdiction while issuing a writ of mandamus directing the state to provide a particular percentage of reservation for sports persons, namely, in the present case, 3 per cent reservation instead of 1 per cent provided by the state government, while exercising powers under Article 226 of the Constitution."

It said the high court judgment is unsustainable and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside.


More News
KCR, Kejriwal teaming up for anti Cong opposition front
6 minutes ago
Honour killing: Traders observe bandh in Begum Bazaar protesting Neeraj’s murder
13 minutes ago
TVS Motor unveils new iQube electric scooter
1 hour ago
'F3' all set for grand release with clean 'U' from Censor Board
1 hour ago
Microsoft founder Bill Gates uses Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 instead Surface Duo
2 hours ago
No clarity so far on Jr NTR's heroine for 'NTR30'
2 hours ago
Aamir to release 'Laal Singh Chaddha' trailer at IPL final on May 29
2 hours ago
BJP-RSS believe India is a geography & polarise: Rahul
2 hours ago
Pawan Kalyan to play a lecturer in Harish Shankar's next film
3 hours ago
I will impress upon BJP to ensure no split in non-YSRCP votes: Pawan Kalyan
3 hours ago
Another honour killing in Hyderabad, Man stabbed to death in public
4 hours ago
IPL 2022: Ashwin happy to contribute with bat and ball in Rajasthan Royals' win
4 hours ago
Gyanvapi row: DU professor arrested for derogatory post
4 hours ago
Apple likely to launch new HomePod by early 2023
4 hours ago
Top 10 destinations for a summer break
4 hours ago
Five destinations to celebrate International Tea Day
5 hours ago
Tributes pour in on Rajiv Gandhi's 31st death anniversary
5 hours ago
Global Covid caseload tops 526.6 mn
6 hours ago
France announces new government
7 hours ago
CEC, EC decide to voluntarily curtail their perks and privileges
7 hours ago