SC junks plea seeking Rs 50 lakh ex-gratia for kin of deceased lawyers

14-09-2021 Tue 14:05 IST | IANS | National

New Delhi, Sep 14 : The Supreme Court on Tuesday junked a PIL seeking direction to the Centre and others to pay Rs 50 lakh ex-gratia to kin of advocates, who died before the age of 60 whether due to Covid-19 or other reasons.

The top court imposed a cost of Rs 10,000 on the petitioner and said life of lawyers cannot be said to be more precious than others.

A bench headed by justice D.Y. Chandrachud noted that the court cannot make an exception for lawyers and cannot encourage filing of bogus PIL by lawyers. The bench also comprising justices Vikram Nath and B.V. Nagarathna told petitioner-in-person advocate Pradeep Kumar Yadav, "Are other people of the society not important". It further added, "This is a publicity interest litigation".

The bench pointed out that several people have succumbed to Covid-19 and cited the judgment passed by the top court dealing with framing of guidelines for compensation to kin of those who have died due to coronavirus. The bench told the lawyer, "Just because you are in black coat does not mean your life is more precious than others".

Yadav had sought Rs 50 lakh for the kin of advocates, who have died within 60 years whether from Covid or any other disease.

The bench reiterated that it is time when it has to stop lawyers from filing bogus PILs. The bench said: "It cannot happen that lawyers file such public interest litigations and demand for compensation from judges and that they will allow". Chiding Yadav, the bench said "You can't be an exception here, Mr Yadav".

The bench also observed that "cut-copy-paste" has been done in the plea and dismissed the petition with a cost of Rs 10,000 payable to the Supreme Court Bar Association within a week.

Yadav argued that all courts are not working, which has impacted the survival of lawyers and their staff. Yadav, in the plea, had arrayed the Centre, Bar Council of India and several other bar bodies as respondents.


More News
Mumbai Police book actor, others for driving ex-Mr India to suicide
8 minutes ago
'Punjipati Pujan Diwas', Congress takes jibe at PM's birthday
11 minutes ago
PM Modi biopic starring Vivek Oberoi to be released on OTT
1 hour ago
MNM chief Kamal Haasan to campaign extensively for rural local body polls
1 hour ago
Telangana HC orders judicial probe into death of rape-murder accused
1 hour ago
Indian cricketers could take part in upcoming Women's Big Bash League
1 hour ago
Ajay Devgn to Anand Mahindra: It was great shooting the truck stunt
1 hour ago
Telangana DGP dismisses doubts over death of rape-murder accused
2 hours ago
SC collegium recommends elevation of 8 CJs to various High Courts
2 hours ago
At 84, this man enrolls to study law in UP varsity
2 hours ago
Political parties celebrate Telangana Merger Day
4 hours ago
Inspiration4: All-civilian team healthy, happy in orbit, says SpaceX
4 hours ago
President, V-P, Rahul, KCR, Jagan and others greet Modi on 71st b'day
5 hours ago
Apple opens pre-orders for iPhone 13 series in India from Friday
5 hours ago
Work-load still not resolved: Will Kohli step down as RCB captain too?
6 hours ago
Afghan economy in despair following Taliban takeover
6 hours ago
Tollywood drugs case: Actor Tanish appears before ED
6 hours ago
Youth attempts 'filmy(Geetha Govindam) style kiss' in bus, girl files complaint
7 hours ago
After dad Mammootty, Dulquer Salmaan also gets UAE Golden Visa
7 hours ago
GST Council meet today: Covid relief, bringing oil and gas indirect tax regime on agenda
7 hours ago
Tharoor accepts apology from Revanth Reddy over 'donkey' remark
7 hours ago
Devotees to have 'darshan' at Ram temple from Dec 2023
9 hours ago
Close-in: IPL cricket circus is back
9 hours ago
Dalai Lama greets Modi on 71st birthday
10 hours ago
Karnataka gears up for Mysuru Dasara, elephants accorded grand welcome
11 hours ago
Woman sentenced to 20 years in jail for sexually abusing boy
11 hours ago
AP cabinet clears implementation of sub-plan for minorities
11 hours ago
TPCC chief Revanth Reddy kicks up a row with his remarks on Shashi Tharoor
11 hours ago
Telangana fixes quota for Gouds, SCs, STs in liquor shop allotment
19 hours ago
PLI scheme to attract Rs 5K cr for drone manufacturing: Minister Jyotiraditya M. Scindia
19 hours ago