SC rules consumer forum can't order forensic test of surveyor's report

28-09-2021 Tue 23:11 IST | IANS | National

New Delhi, Sep 28:  The Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled that a consumer forum is primarily concerned with an allegation of deficiency in service and cannot subject the surveyor's report to forensic examination.

A bench of Justices Hemant Gupta and V. Ramasubramanian said: "Once it is found that there was no inadequacy in the quality, nature, and manner of performance of the duties and responsibilities of the surveyor, in a manner prescribed by the Regulations as to their code of conduct and once it is found that the report is not based on adhocism or vitiated by arbitrariness, then the jurisdiction of the Consumer Forum to go further would stop."

The bench noted the present case is not a case where the insurance company has repudiated the claim of the appellant arbitrarily or on unjustifiable grounds. This is a case where the claim of the appellant has been admitted, to the extent of the loss as assessed by the surveyor, it added.

The bench said: "A consumer forum which is primarily concerned with an allegation of deficiency in service cannot subject the surveyor's report to forensic examination of its anatomy, just as a civil court could do."

The top court's judgment assumes significance, against the backdrop that the firm sought increasing the insured amount, pointing that loss of articles was not properly assessed.

The bench upheld the findings of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC), which said that the firm was "not entitled to succeed unless they were able to establish any deficiency in service on the part of the insurance company."

The bench said since the claim was admitted, then the jurisdiction of the special forum constituted under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 is limited. It added, "perhaps if the appellant had gone to the civil court, they could have even summoned the surveyor and cross-examined him on every minute detail. But in a complaint before the Consumer Forum, a consumer cannot succeed unless he establishes deficiency in service on the part of the service provider".

The top court judgment came on an appeal of firm Khatema Fibres Ltd challenging the NCDRC order, which held that its insurer, New India Assurance Company Ltd, was obligated to pay Rs 2.86 crore as insurance claim, according to the report submitted by the surveyor.

A fire had broke out in the factory premises on November 15, 2007, and the firm claimed the quantity of waste paper destroyed was 8,500 MT and valued it at Rs 13 crore.


More News
'Jumbo Savari' takes place within Mysuru Palace premises on Dasara
10 hours ago
At Dussehra Rally, Uddhav Thackeray takes aim at several political 'Ravanas'
11 hours ago
British MP stabbed to death at church, suspect held
11 hours ago
Need to focus on expanding primary vax coverage before boosters: WHO's Swaminathan
11 hours ago
Telangana CM, Governor performs Vahan, Ayudha puja
11 hours ago
President pays tributes at the Kargil War Memorial
11 hours ago
SRK and his history of being a controversy magnet
12 hours ago
Owaisi dismisses RSS chief's claim of increase in Muslim population
12 hours ago
Andhra Pradesh for simultaneous handover of projects to KRMB
13 hours ago
IPL 2021: CSK's Ruturaj Gaikwad becomes youngest Orange Cup holder in league's history
13 hours ago
MS Dhoni becomes first captain to lead in 300 T20 matches
14 hours ago
Weeklong Kullu Dussehra festival begins with 170 deities
14 hours ago
Chief Justice of India offers prayers at Tirumala
14 hours ago
CPI-Maoist confirms death of top leader R.K. due to kidney failure
14 hours ago
Prashanth Neel of 'KGF' fame to direct Ram Charan
14 hours ago
Kerala's first artificial heart implantation done successfully
14 hours ago
Kohli shares hilarious photo describing 'what playing in bubbles feels like'
14 hours ago
Hubble finds persistent water vapour in Jupiter's moon
14 hours ago
India's defence exports increased by 325% in last 5 years: Modi
15 hours ago
Negative calorie food
16 hours ago
Ilaiyaraaja's 'Music School' set to roll with muhurat puja on Dussehra
16 hours ago
Tighten security in smaller cities in festive season, Centre tells states
16 hours ago
India 6th most affected country by ransomware: Google
17 hours ago
Suriya's legal thriller 'Jai Bhim' to be streamed on Amazon Prime Video on Nov 2
17 hours ago
Samantha announces her next film with Shantaruban Gnanasekharan
17 hours ago
Freedom, Mahatma, 'Gen Next English' figure in Aryan Khan bail feud
17 hours ago
Special offer at MP petrol pump to celebrate birth of owner's grand-niece
18 hours ago
Biden signs short-term bill to raise debt limit
18 hours ago
Little girl helps Warner make his choice on who he should support in IPL final. It's CSK!
18 hours ago
Tatas plan to pilot synergy between airlines, post SPA
18 hours ago