Denying unmarried woman right to safe abortion violates her personal autonomy: SC

21-07-2022 Thu 22:17 IST | IANS | National
Denying unmarried woman right to safe abortion violates her personal autonomy: SC

New Delhi, July 21:  The Supreme Court on Thursday said live-in relationships have been recognised by it and denying an unmarried woman the right to a safe abortion violates her personal autonomy and freedom.

Noting said statutes have recognised the reproductive choice of a woman and her bodily integrity and autonomy and both these rights embody the notion that a choice must inhere in a woman on whether or not to bear a child, it said while allowing the examination of a 24-week pregnant unmarried woman by an AIIMS medical board to determine whether the pregnancy can be safely terminated without endangering her life.

A bench, headed by Justice D.Y. Chandrachud and comprising Justices Surya Kant and A.S. Bopanna, said: "A woman's right to reproductive choice is an inseparable part of her personal liberty under Article 21 of Constitution. She has a sacrosanct right to bodily integrity.

"Denying an unmarried woman the right to a safe abortion violates her personal autonomy and freedom. Live-in relationships have been recognised by this court."

The bench said letting an unmarried woman suffer an unwanted pregnancy will be contrary to the object and spirit of the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act.

The bench said that the Parliament, by amending the MTP Act through Act 8 of 2021, intended to include unmarried women and single women within the ambit of the Act. This is evident from the replacement of the word 'husband' with 'partner' in explanation I of Section 3(2) of the Act, it added.

"Moreover, allowing the petitioner to terminate her pregnancy, on a proper interpretation of the statute, prima facie, falls within the ambit of the statute and the petitioner should not be denied the benefit on the ground that she is an unmarried woman," it said.

The bench said the distinction between a married and unmarried woman does not bear a nexus to the basic purpose and object which is sought to be achieved by Parliament which is conveyed specifically by the provisions of Explanation 1 to Section 3 of the Act.

As the petitioner had moved the Delhi High Court before she had completed 24 weeks of pregnancy, the bench said the delay in the judicial process cannot work to her prejudice.

The top court asked the AIIMS, Delhi, Director to constitute a medical board in terms of the provisions of Section 3(2D) of the Act.

"In the event that the medical board concludes that the foetus can be aborted without danger to the life of the petitioner, a team of doctors at the AIIMS shall carry out the abortion in terms of the request which has been made before the High Court," it said.

Citing the MTP amendment 2021, the bench said the parliamentary intent is clearly not to confine the beneficial provisions of the MTP Act only to a situation involving a matrimonial relationship. "On the contrary, a reference to the expression 'any woman or her partner' would indicate that a broad meaning and intent has been intended to be ascribed by Parliament. The statute has recognized the reproductive choice of a woman and her bodily integrity and autonomy," it added.

The bench observed that both these rights embody the notion that a choice must inhere in a woman on whether or not to bear a child. "In recognising the right, the legislature has not intended to make a distinction between a married and unmarried woman, in her ability to make a decision on whether or not to bear the child," it said.

The bench said prima facie, quite apart from the issue of constitutionality which has been addressed before the high court, it appears that it has taken an unduly restrictive view of the provisions of clause (c) of Rule 3B. "Clause (c) speaks of a change of marital status during an ongoing pregnancy and is followed in parenthesis by the words 'widowhood and divorce'. The expression 'change of marital status' should be given a purposive rather than a restrictive interpretation. The expressions 'widowhood and divorce' need not be construed to be exhaustive of the category which precedes it," it said.

On July 16, the Delhi High Court, while refusing to entertain a plea seeking termination of a 23-week pregnancy, observed that the petitioner, a 25-year-old unmarried Manipuri woman, whose pregnancy arises out of a consensual relationship, is clearly not covered by any of the clauses under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Rules, 2003. The woman stated in her plea that she cannot give birth to the child as she is an unmarried woman and her partner has refused to marry her.

It further stated that giving birth out of wedlock will entail in her ostracisation and cause her mental agony. As she is solely a B.A. graduate who is non-working, she will not be able to raise and handle the child, the woman submitted in her petition, stating that she is not mentally prepared to be a mother and continuing with the pregnancy will lead to grave physical and mental injury for her.

The woman moved the top court, which entertained her plea, challenging this high court order.


More News
American fans go bonkers over ‘Naatu Naatu song’ from 'RRR', dance in front of screen
5 hours ago
'Word of mouth' real review, opines Akkineni Nagarjuna while promoting 'The Ghost'
6 hours ago
PM Modi undisputed king of social media; brand value Rs 413 crore, says CheckBrand
7 hours ago
Chiranjeevi opens up on ‘Acharya’ failure, says outcome not in our hands
7 hours ago
Botsa reiterates decentralised development is YSRCP govt’s policy
9 hours ago
TDP official Twitter account hacked, YSRCP’s role alleged
10 hours ago
Ambati throws debate challenge to Harish Rao on welfare in Telugu states
11 hours ago
Srikalahasti CI in news for wrong reasons
12 hours ago
Brickbats followed by bouquets from Union Ministers on Telangana CM: KCR
13 hours ago
Hyd: Chiranjeevi opens Allu Studios, Allu Arjun thanks megastar
14 hours ago
Rahul’s Bharat Jodo Yatra in Telangana from Oct 24: Revanth
14 hours ago
Dasara gift: Telangana govt issued GO enhancing ST quota from 6 to 10%
16 hours ago
Actor Prudviraj gets shocker as family court asks him to pay monthly Rs 8 lakh to wife
16 hours ago
Bandla Ganesh in awe of Pawan Kalyan's looks; posts photos on social media
1 day ago
T20 World Cup prize money announced by ICC; winners to take away Rs 13 crore
1 day ago
Namrata Shirodkar’s heartfelt post on her mother-in-law Indira Devi moves netizens
1 day ago
Akkineni Nagarjuna's action-packed 'Ghost' trailer unveiled; film to hit screens on Oct 5
1 day ago
Criticise KCR not AP if Harish Rao has issues with him: AP Minister Amarnath
1 day ago
SS Rajamouli to watch RRR on world’s biggest IMAX theatre
1 day ago
Pawan Kalyan’s stylish look at HHVM workshop goes viral on social media
1 day ago
Advertisement
Advertisement
Video News
9 PM Telugu News: 1st October 2022
9 PM Telugu News: 1st October 2022
4 hours ago
Advertisement 36
Viral: Impromptu Garba at Bengaluru airport as passengers join staff to celebrate Navaratri
Viral: Impromptu Garba at Bengaluru airport as passengers join staff to celebrate Navaratri
5 hours ago
Special Story on CM KCR National Politics
Special Story on CM KCR National Politics
6 hours ago
Video: Huge Avalanche hits mountains around Kedarnath Temple
Video: Huge Avalanche hits mountains around Kedarnath Temple
6 hours ago
Samantha changes Insta bio to a cryptic note amid health scare rumours
Samantha changes Insta bio to a cryptic note amid health scare rumours
7 hours ago
Actor Pruthviraj gets a shocker from Court
Actor Pruthviraj gets a shocker from Court
7 hours ago
South Vs Bollywood: Salman Khan and Chiranjeevi unexpected reply
South Vs Bollywood: Salman Khan and Chiranjeevi unexpected reply
8 hours ago
A girl with a urn on her head dances while cycling and letting both hands free-Viral
A girl with a urn on her head dances while cycling and letting both hands free-Viral
8 hours ago
AP Minister Ambati Rambabu challenges Telangana Minister Harish Rao
AP Minister Ambati Rambabu challenges Telangana Minister Harish Rao
9 hours ago
President Droupadi Murmu presents awards for ‘Azadi@ 75 Swachh Survekshan-2022'
President Droupadi Murmu presents awards for ‘Azadi@ 75 Swachh Survekshan-2022'
10 hours ago
From now on, my sons will take care of Allu Studios, Geetha Arts, says Allu Aravind
From now on, my sons will take care of Allu Studios, Geetha Arts, says Allu Aravind
10 hours ago
Salman Khan and Chiranjeevi arrive in style and pose for pics at GodFather pre-release event
Salman Khan and Chiranjeevi arrive in style and pose for pics at GodFather pre-release event
10 hours ago