No absolute right of employee for representation of choice in dept proceedings: SC

04-01-2022 Tue 22:57 IST | IANS | National
No absolute right of employee for representation of choice in dept proceedings: SC

New Delhi, Jan 4:  The Supreme Court on Tuesday observed that there is no absolute right in favour of the delinquent employee, to be represented by an agent of his choice, in departmental proceedings.

A bench of Justices M.R. Shah and Sanjiv Khanna said: "The only requirement is that delinquent officer must be given fair opportunity to represent his case and that there is no absolute right in his favour to be represented through the agent of his choice."

The bench said however, at the same time, if the charge is severe and complex nature, then request to be represented through a counsel can be considered keeping in mind Regulation 44 of Regulations 2010 and if in a particular case, the same is denied, that can be ground to challenge the ultimate outcome of the departmental enquiry.

"However, as a matter of right in each and every case, irrespective of whether charges is severe and complex nature or not, the employee as a matter of right cannot pray that he may be permitted to represent through the agent of his choice," it added.

The top court allowed the appeal filed by the Rajasthan Marudhara Gramin Bank, challenging the single judge bench's order, confirmed by a division bench of the high court, permitting the delinquent employee who is facing disciplinary proceedings to be represented through an ex-employee of the bank.

The top court quashed the high court order, which observed that the Regulation 44 only restricts representation by a legal practitioner, and even that too is permissible with permission of competent authority, and the employee cannot be restrained from availing services of a retired employee of a bank.

The top court noted that in the departmental proceedings, the right to be represented through counsel or agent can be restricted, controlled or regulated by statute, rules, regulations, or standing orders.



More News
DGCA warns airlines against offering unserviceable seats
4 hours ago
Aishwarya Rai's modelling bill from '92 surfaces; she was paid Rs 1,500!
4 hours ago
BFI, SAI felicitate World Championships medallists Nikhat, Parveen and Manisha
4 hours ago
Violence in Andhra town over renaming district after Ambedkar
6 hours ago
Hyderabad youth jailed for 15 days for sending obscene photos
6 hours ago
India-Japan agree to enhance bilateral security & defence cooperation
6 hours ago
Public confidence must for using facial recognition with AI: KTR
6 hours ago
Will fight attempts of Centre to target my father through me: Karti Chidambaram
6 hours ago
KCR to avoid meeting PM Modi again
8 hours ago
TDP, Jana Sena behind violence in Amalapuram over district renaming row: Minister Viswarup
9 hours ago
Modi meets chairperson of Japan-India Association in Tokyo
10 hours ago
Proposed GPS to govt staff after assessing state’s financial position: Sajjala
10 hours ago
Drones prohibited around ISB Hyderabad for PM's visit
10 hours ago
PM to visit Hyderabad, Chennai on May 26 for various programmes
10 hours ago
AI to make roads in India safer to drive
10 hours ago
KTR meets Andhra CM Jagan, Aaditya Thackeray
11 hours ago
Gudur: Gang war between B. Tech & polytechnic students of Audisankara Engg College
11 hours ago
Why YSRCP, TDP, Jana Sena scared of BJP, asks Vundavalli
11 hours ago
TPCC chief Revanth is blackmailer, alleges Minister Malla Reddy
12 hours ago
I look forward to further strengthening Olympic Movement in India: Nita Ambani on launch of OVEP in Odisha
13 hours ago