No abetment conviction without positive act to instigate/aid suicide: SC

17-09-2021 Fri 23:06 IST | IANS | National

New Delhi, Sep 17:  The Supreme Court on Friday held that abetment involves mental process of instigating or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing, as it quashed criminal proceedings and a non-bailable warrant issued against a woman in a case of an alleged suicide under the SC/ST Act.

A bench of Justices R. Subhash Reddy and Hrishikesh Roy said: "Abetment involves mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, no one can be convicted for offence under Section 306, IPC."

The bench observed that to proceed against any person for the offence under Section 306, it requires an active or direct act which led the deceased see no option but to commit suicide, and that the act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide.

It noted that there is nothing on record to show that the petitioner was maintaining a relation with the deceased and further there is absolutely no material to allege she abetted suicide of the deceased within the meaning of Section 306.

"Except the statement that the deceased was in relation with the appellant, there is no material at all to show that appellant was maintaining any relation with the deceased," said the top court.

The bench added that it would be travesty of justice to compel the appellant to face a criminal trial without any credible material whatsoever.

The top court's judgment came on an appeal filed by a woman challenging the Allahabad High Court order, which dismissed her plea seeking to quash criminal proceedings and the NBW issued for offences under sections various sections of The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and Section 306 of IPC.

In May 2018, an FIR was registered at TP Nagar Police Station in Meerut district on the complaint of a man alleging that his brother was called by the petitioner at her house wherein her parents and sister made casteist abuses and forcefully administered poison to him and consequently his brother became unconscious. The complainant claimed his brother died at the hospital due to negligence.

Setting aside the high court order, the bench said: "Except the self-serving statements of the complainant and other witnesses stating that the deceased was in love with the appellant, there is no other material to show that appellant was maintaining any relation with the deceased".



More News
French Open: Sindhu advances to 2nd round, Saina pulls out with injury
50 minutes ago
Andhra earmarks 35% BTech, Agri seats in pvt varsities under govt quota
2 hours ago
BCCI president Ganguly quits position at ATK to avoid conflict of interest
9 hours ago
When Sundar Pichai went mute during chat with Kermit The Frog
9 hours ago
CBI files charge sheet in the murder of Vivekananda Reddy
9 hours ago
Train runs back to save woman, newborn
10 hours ago
Another rare honour for breast cancer surgeon Raghu Ram
10 hours ago
Chiranjeevi to bear expenses for fan's cancer treatment
10 hours ago
National security not always a 'free pass' against judiciary, says SC on Pegasus
10 hours ago
Amit Shah speaks to Chandrababu Naidu on Andhra developments
10 hours ago
Tourism projects worth Rs 2,868 crore to come up in Andhra Pradesh
11 hours ago
NCB team questions Wankhede for over four hours
11 hours ago
Defence invokes Aryan's constitutional rights, matter adjourned to Thursday
12 hours ago
T20 World Cup: Sania Mirza comes to Mohammad Hafeez's rescue, arranges birthday cake for his wife
12 hours ago
Aamir Khan's salt and pepper look goes viral
12 hours ago
Fans await dialogue promo or song from Pawan Kalyan starrer 'Bheemla Nayak' makers
12 hours ago
Right to privacy infringed in spying, be it by state or others, says SC on Pegasus
13 hours ago
'Ghani Anthem' matches the spirit of sports drama
14 hours ago
Shoaib Akhtar walks out of talk show after being 'insulted' on national TV
16 hours ago
Telangana to further intensify Covid vaccination
17 hours ago
Andhra Pradesh is narcotics hub of India: Pawan Kalyan
17 hours ago
Prabhas' good-humoured 'interview' with Akash, Ketika goes viral
18 hours ago
KTR leaves for Paris to address 'Ambition India Business Forum'
18 hours ago
Huzurabad witnesses intense canvassing on last day
19 hours ago
Nawab Malik alleges Wankhede's links with global drugs mafia, seeks probe
19 hours ago
Pegasus row: SC sets up committee headed by retired judge to probe snooping allegations
20 hours ago
Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin to build a private space station by 2030
20 hours ago
Now Nawab Malik celebrates 'nikaah' of 'sweet couple Sameer Dawood Wankhede-Shabana Quraishi'
21 hours ago
Waqar Younis apologises 'with folded hands' after controversial remark
22 hours ago
Users can now transfer WhatsApp chats from iOS to Pixel, Android 12 phones
22 hours ago