Parties in commercial litigation should avoid filing mindless appeals, says SC

17-09-2021 Fri 21:33 IST | IANS | National

New Delhi, Sep 17: The Supreme Court on Friday observed that parties engaged in commercial litigation must weigh the commercial interests and avoid filing mindless appeals.

A bench of Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Hrishikesh Roy said: "In carrying on commercial litigation, parties must weigh the commercial interests, which would include the consequences of the matter not receiving favourable consideration by the courts. Mindless appeals should not be the rule."

The bench noted that tender jurisdiction was created for scrutiny of commercial matters and, thus, where continuously parties seek to challenge award of tenders.

"We are of the view that the succeeding party must get costs and the party which loses must pay costs. This was really a battle between two commercial entities on one side seeking to get set aside an award of a tender to two other entities. What else would be commercial interest!" it said, while allowing an appeal by company, UFLEX Ltd, against the order passed by the Madras High Court allowing two other companies which were unsuccessful at a government bidding, to draw a "share of the pie".

"We are thus unequivocally of the view that the impugned order cannot be sustained for all the aforesaid reasons and must be set aside and the appeals are accordingly allowed," said the bench, directing the respondent companies to pay a sum of Rs 23 lakh to the petitioner and Rs 7.5 lakh to the state government for litigation expenses.

The bench noted there is often a hesitancy in the judicial system to impose costs, presuming as if it is a reflection on counsel. "In a tussle for enforcement of rights against state, different principle apply but in commercial matters, costs must follow the cause," it added in the 48-page judgment.

The case in connected with the Tami Nadu government's attempt to contain the sale of spurious liquor by deciding to paste stickers on every liquor bottle and invite tenders for this.

Many companies submitted their bids. Two companies challenged the process before Madras High Court without participating in the bidding, claiming that the tender was designed in a way, which allowed few companies to participate.

The division bench of the high court in April this year gave the Tamil Nadu government four months' time to float a fresh tender, while permitting the existing successful tenderers to continue to provide the supplies under the same terms and conditions. The successful bidder, UFLEX Ltd, moved the top court challenging this order.



More News
Telangana releases Rs 250 cr for Dalit Bandhu in 4 mandals
5 hours ago
China's 'unscientific approach' banning Indians from travelling to China
6 hours ago
T20 World Cup Warm-up: Ishan, Rahul star as India beat England
6 hours ago
Economy healing but still digging out of deep economic contraction: RBI
6 hours ago
EC orders Telangana to stop Dalit Bandhu in Huzurabad
6 hours ago
Flame for Beijing 2022 Winter Games lit in Ancient Olympia
7 hours ago
RBI imposes Rs 1 cr penalty on SBI
7 hours ago
Telangana to procure paddy through 6,545 centres
7 hours ago
Kin of Andhra employees died of Covid to get jobs
7 hours ago
Telangana to formulate strategy to curb drug menace
7 hours ago
Noted Kannada actor, comedian Shankar Rao passes away
7 hours ago
India and China to drive global aviation Satcom market
7 hours ago
Former Andhra minister Mothkupalli Narasimhulu joins TRS
8 hours ago
Taliban's Dy Foreign Minister Stanikzai flees to Dubai, as cracks appear in extremist fortress
8 hours ago
India, Bangladesh set to hold high-level talks to expand connectivity through waterways
8 hours ago
Jaishankar invites Israeli companies to invest in India's post-Covid surge
8 hours ago
We need to create a cricketing bond: Raja on meeting with Ganguly and Shah
8 hours ago
GIS-based Geospatial Energy Map of India launched
8 hours ago
NCP minister dares NCB to prove claims of Aryan Khan's 'remorse'
8 hours ago
Tamil star Suriya plays tribal rights advocate in 'Jai Bhim'
8 hours ago
Under new CEO, T-Hub announces expansion
8 hours ago
T20 World Cup: #BoycottPakistan trends on social media ahead of Indo-Pak clash
9 hours ago
IndiGo draws defensive lines to ward-off upcoming competition
9 hours ago
Bhawani Mandi: A railway station where trains stand in two states
9 hours ago
Health Ministry's eSanjeevani registers 1.4 cr consultations
9 hours ago
Hrithik Roshan's dance videos go viral, break the Net
9 hours ago
Katrina Kaif looks stunning in beach pics, reels
10 hours ago
Bhupesh Baghel is India's best performing Chief Minister
10 hours ago
India, Israel agree to mutually recognize Covid vax certification
10 hours ago
Rail roko: Train services disrupted at 130 places
10 hours ago