Assuming every Covid death was due to medical negligence is too much: SC

08-09-2021 Wed 15:34 IST | IANS | Health

New Delhi, Sep 8:  The Supreme Court on Wednesday said presuming all deaths due to Covid-19 during the second wave of the pandemic were due to negligence would be "too much".

A bench headed by Justice D.Y. Chandrachud said: "To assume that each death due to Covid-19 took place due to negligence is too much".

The bench observed that though the second wave had an impact across the country, however, it cannot be presumed that all deaths occurred due to negligence.

"Courts cannot have a presumption that all Covid deaths happened due to medical negligence", said the bench also comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Hima Kohli, as it refused to entertain a plea seeking compensation for the kin of the victims by treating it as medical negligence.

Advocate Sriram Parakat, representing the petitioner, contended before the bench this petition is different. He added that the petition focuses on the element of negligence and compensation for the deaths which occurred due to medical negligence.

The bench told the petitioner Deepak Raj Singh counsel to move competent authorities with his suggestions and also cited the top court's June 30 judgment, directing the National Disaster Management Authority to frame appropriate guidelines within six weeks for ex-gratia assistance for family members of persons who succumbed to Covid.

Referring this judgment, the top court said the court has taken a view with regard to humanity and not due to negligence. It further added, "The government is yet to come out with the policy. If you have any suggestion with regard to implementation of that policy, you can approach the competent authority".

The bench noted that the top court has already taken suo motu cognizance on Covid preparedness and a national task force has been constituted by it to examine several aspects.

The bench reiterated that it is not possible to make a general presumption of medical negligence as the reason behind deaths due to Covid.

After hearing arguments on the matter, the top court asked the petitioner to withdraw his plea and move before a competent authority.



More News
India sets record of over 2 cr vaccinations in a day
5 hours ago
Change in Afghanistan was not inclusive, sans negotiation: Modi
5 hours ago
Majority of Council opposed bringing petroleum products under GST: Sitharaman
5 hours ago
No abetment conviction without positive act to instigate/aid suicide: SC
5 hours ago
Woman Maoist leader surrenders before Telangana DGP
5 hours ago
YSRCP protest at Chandrababu Naidu's house leads to tension, clash
6 hours ago
Parties in commercial litigation should avoid filing mindless appeals, says SC
7 hours ago
GST Council extends levy of compensation cess till March 2026
7 hours ago
Andhra to seek Centre's support to develop infra in tribal areas
7 hours ago
Telangana attracts Rs 887 crore investment in jute sector
8 hours ago
Millets in daily diet will fight malnutrition: Agriculture Minister
8 hours ago
Mumbai Police book actor, others for driving ex-Mr India to suicide
9 hours ago
'Punjipati Pujan Diwas', Congress takes jibe at PM's birthday
9 hours ago
PM Modi biopic starring Vivek Oberoi to be released on OTT
10 hours ago
MNM chief Kamal Haasan to campaign extensively for rural local body polls
10 hours ago
Telangana HC orders judicial probe into death of rape-murder accused
10 hours ago
Indian cricketers could take part in upcoming Women's Big Bash League
11 hours ago
Ajay Devgn to Anand Mahindra: It was great shooting the truck stunt
11 hours ago
Telangana DGP dismisses doubts over death of rape-murder accused
11 hours ago
SC collegium recommends elevation of 8 CJs to various High Courts
12 hours ago
At 84, this man enrolls to study law in UP varsity
12 hours ago
Political parties celebrate Telangana Merger Day
14 hours ago
Inspiration4: All-civilian team healthy, happy in orbit, says SpaceX
14 hours ago
President, V-P, Rahul, KCR, Jagan and others greet Modi on 71st b'day
15 hours ago
Apple opens pre-orders for iPhone 13 series in India from Friday
15 hours ago
Work-load still not resolved: Will Kohli step down as RCB captain too?
15 hours ago
Afghan economy in despair following Taliban takeover
15 hours ago
Tollywood drugs case: Actor Tanish appears before ED
15 hours ago
Youth attempts 'filmy(Geetha Govindam) style kiss' in bus, girl files complaint
16 hours ago
After dad Mammootty, Dulquer Salmaan also gets UAE Golden Visa
16 hours ago