SC: Future rise in income applicable even if deceased wasn't earning at time of accident

19-11-2021 Fri 22:14 IST | IANS | National
SC: Future rise in income applicable even if deceased wasn't earning at time of accident

New Delhi, Nov 19 : The Supreme Court has held that a future increase in income of an accident victim should be considered while determining compensation in motor accident claims.

A bench comprising justices M.R. Shah and Sanjiv Khanna said: "We are of the opinion that even in case of a deceased who was not serving at the time of death and had no income at the time of death, his legal heirs shall also be entitled to future prospects by adding future rise in income as held by this court."

The bench cited an earlier judgment where the addition of 40 per cent of the income determined on guesswork considering the educational qualification, family background etc. was taken into account when the deceased was below the age of 40 years.

The deceased's family counsel cited the victim's educational qualifications and his bright future and contended that the high court committed an error in fixing the future income at Rs 5,000 per month and did not consider the future rise in income. Prashant (21), at the time of the accident, was in their third year of engineering.

The Centre's counsel argued that since the deceased was not earning anything at the time of the accident, there would not be any future rise in income. The bench noted that in the case of a deceased, who was not earning or not doing any job or was self-employed at the time of death, his income has to be determined on the guesswork looking into the circumstances.

"The perception that he is likely to remain static and his income would remain stagnant is contrary to the fundamental concept of human attitude, which always intends to live with dynamism and move and change with the time," said the bench.

The top court was hearing an appeal by Prashant's family members against the Madhya Pradesh High Court order, which partly allowed the appeal by the Railways and reduced the amount of compensation from Rs 12,85,000 to Rs 6,10,000.

Prashant's family had filed a claim petition before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (MACT) for Rs 25 lakh compensation. However, the MACT in toto awarded Rs 12,85,000 with 7.5 per cent interest per annum. The family then moved to the high court, which reduced the amount to Rs 6,10,000 after assessing the income of the deceased at Rs 5,000 per month.

The top court said the income of the deceased at least ought to have been considered at Rs 10,000/per month, more particularly considering the fact that the labourers/skilled labourers were getting Rs 5,000/per month even under the Minimum Wages Act in the year 2012.

The top court directed that Prashant's family members be entitled to a sum of Rs 15,82,000 with interest at the rate of 7 per cent per annum.


More News
Father liable to maintain son till he becomes a major, rules SC
6 hours ago
We have had good preparation going into 2022 Women's World Cup: Mithali Raj
6 hours ago
Two killed as car falls into well, rescue worker also loses life
6 hours ago
Need umbrella body for judicial infrastructure requirements: SC
6 hours ago
Parliamentary panel recommends reconstitution of Press Council
7 hours ago
Parliament delegation from Mongolia calls on President Kovind
7 hours ago
House made out of 65 herbal plants, mud comes up in Kerala
7 hours ago
BJP 'victimised' Shah Rukh, Mahesh Bhatt, says Mamata
7 hours ago
Farm Laws Repeal Act 2021 gets Presidential assent
7 hours ago
Andhra employees to launch agitation over demands
11 hours ago
PM Modi holds meeting with senior cabinet ministers
11 hours ago
Cardiologists to deliberate on detecting heart ailments in advance
11 hours ago
Telugu actor Sumanth dubs for Ranveer Singh-starrer '83'
11 hours ago
BWF World Tour Finals: Sindhu, Srikanth make winning starts; Ponnappa-Sikki lose
11 hours ago
Now scan documents with your Google Chromebook camera
11 hours ago
Kamal Haasan recovers from Covid, will be fully fit soon
11 hours ago
Bus fares to go up in Telangana
11 hours ago
Ram Charan on working with Shanmugam: 'I'm having a fanboy moment on the sets'
11 hours ago
FIR against Zukerberg for FB post against Akhilesh
14 hours ago
Hyderabad's Sunday-Funday event called off in view of Omicron concerns
14 hours ago
Tension during 'Mahapadyatra' by Amaravati farmers
14 hours ago
Blingy 'Pushpa' set for Samantha's item number as she jives with Allu Arjun
15 hours ago
Chiranjeevi on Sirivennela: We were hoping to get advanced treatment for him
16 hours ago
Mysuru on alert as 72 nursing students test positive for Covid-19
17 hours ago
Covid infection raises complications in pregnancy, birth
17 hours ago
Tirumala ghat road closed again following landslides
18 hours ago
Apple launches new limited-edition Beats Studio Buds
18 hours ago
Raashi Khanna keeps promise, makes planting a sapling on birthday a tradition
18 hours ago
Twitter bans sharing of images, videos without people's consent
18 hours ago
Rajamouli mourns 'Dosti' lyricist Seetharama Sastry's demise
19 hours ago