Very unhappy: SC on Centre's cherry-picking tribunals' appointments

15-09-2021 Wed 12:33 IST | IANS | National

New Delhi, Sep 15 : The Supreme Court on Wednesday criticised the government for "cherry-picking" from its recommendations for tribunals across the country, asking what is the sanctity of recommendations by the panel headed by sitting top court judges if the government has the last say on the matter.

A bench headed by Chief Justice N.V. Ramana, and comprising Justices D.Y. Chandrachud and L. Nageswara Rao told Attorney General K.K. Venugopal, representing the Centre, that it is "very unhappy" with the way the Centre has made appointments to the tribunals.

It clearly told the him it did not appreciate the Centre's "cherry-picking" names for appointment after recommendations made by the Search-cum-Selection Committees (SCSC) headed by Supreme Court judges.

Emphasising that it is distressing that names recommended by selection panel, which comprised of sitting top court judges and two senior bureaucrats, were not treated seriously, the top court gave Centre two weeks, as the last opportunity, to make good the appointments and furnish reasons for the names, which were rejected.

"We are very unhappy with what is going on," noted the Chief Justice, while questioning the Centre as to why recommendations made by the SCSC were not accepted. The SCSC shortlists candidates for appointment and then sends it to the Centre for clearance.

"Make all appointments. We give you two weeks' time," said the bench.

The bench pointed out that the SCSC recommended nine judicial members and 10 technical members for National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and the appointment letter issued showed "as if members were cherry-picked and some were kept on waiting".

"We cannot ignore selected candidates and go to waitlist. What type of selection and appointment is this?"

As the AG contended before the bench that the government has power not to accept the recommendation, the Chief Justice responded that in a democracy, one cannot say recommendations cannot be accepted. "What is the sanctity of recommendations made by panel headed by sitting top court judges, if the government has the last say on the matter?" he asked

"I have seen the NCLT (National Company Law Tribunal) appointments.... more recommendations were made. But in appointments, cherry-picking was done."

Expressing unhappiness with the decisions, he added: "What kind of selection is this? Same thing done with ITAT (Income Tax Appellate Tribunal) members also."

Chief Justice Ramana further added that he is also part of the NCLT selection committee and pointed out the committee interviewed 544 people, out of which 11 names were given for judicial members and 10 technical members. "From all of these recommendations, only some of them were appointed by the government... rest of the names went to (the) wait list... we wasted our time," he said.

Justice Chandrachud pointed out that people are left in lurch, when they go to the high courts, they are told to go to tribunals. He added, "But there are vacancies in tribunals".

The apex court was hearing a batch of petitions raising the issue of vacancies in various tribunals and also a petition, by senior Congress leader Jairam Ramesh, challenging certain provisions of The Tribunal Reforms Act, 2021.


More News
Jeff Bezos pledges $1 bn fund to boost conservation
38 minutes ago
Taliban admire Imran Khan's efforts for Afghanistan
1 hour ago
TRS, Congress workers clash at Revanth Reddy's residence
2 hours ago
Lakshmi Manchu had a blast hosting SIIMA awards
2 hours ago
SC collegium recommends 13 Chief Justices for various HCs
2 hours ago
Apple iOS 15 is now available to download
2 hours ago
YS Sharmila detained during weekly fast over unemployment
3 hours ago
Telangana man who built KCR temple puts it on sale
3 hours ago
In a first, MHA approves trial for shock batons for CAPF
3 hours ago
Musk mocks Biden for not appreciating SpaceX's historic civilian flight
3 hours ago
Taliban names remaining Ministers in caretaker govt
3 hours ago
Gautam Adani says on track to be the world's largest renewable generating company
4 hours ago
TSRTC restores 100 per cent services in Greater Hyderabad
4 hours ago
Amazon pays Rs 8,546 crore as legal fees in India to remain operational
6 hours ago
'It was pre-planned': Payal Ghosh on suspected 'acid attack'
6 hours ago
Armaan Malik on winning SIIMA award: 'Butta Bomma' one of my most memorable songs
6 hours ago
Myth or Fact: Exercise must be avoided after a heart attack
7 hours ago
At 26,115 new Covid cases, India sees dip in infections
8 hours ago
Apple hits record pre-orders in India with iPhone 13
8 hours ago
Sleep apnea affects 40L people in India
9 hours ago
Google Pixel 6 Pro specifications leaked ahead of launch
9 hours ago
Covid, climate crisis, Afghanistan to dominate UNGA
10 hours ago
US to ease travel curbs for fully vaccinated foreign visitors
11 hours ago
Refugees may pose Pakistan's biggest problem
12 hours ago
US Covid-19 fatalities surpass 1918 flu estimates
12 hours ago
Airport-like facilities for passengers at New Delhi rly station
12 hours ago
Rajiv assassination case: OPS seeks Stalin's intervention for release of life convicts
21 hours ago
IPL 2021: Kolkata Knight Riders thrash Royal Challengers Bangalore by nine wickets
21 hours ago
A greater India is visibly an India for Indians: Gautam Adani
21 hours ago
Amid global rout Sensex plunges over 500 points (Roundup)
21 hours ago