Beating around the bush: SC on Centre's denial on detailed affidavit in Pegasus row

13-09-2021 Mon 15:12 IST | IANS | National

New Delhi, Sep 13 : After the Centre's denial to file a detailed affidavit clarifying whether Pegasus spyware was used or not, the Supreme Court on Monday reserved its order on a batch of petitions seeking independent probe into the alleged Pegasus snooping case.

A bench headed by Cheif Justice N.V. Ramana and comprising justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli said the court will pass an interim order in the next few days and told the Centre that beating around the bush would not take the issue anywhere.

"Beating around the bush...we will pass some interim order," the chief justice told Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Centre.

The Centre informed the bench that it is not going to file a detailed affidavit, after taking time twice to take a decision, whether it will file an affidavit or not on a batch of petitions seeking inquiry into alleged use of spyware Pegasus.

Mehta submitted that government can constitute technical committee of independent domain experts, who can examine the petitioners' allegations that their phones were affected by Pegasus. Centre said this committee can submit its report to the top court.

The top court pointed at the response of former Minister for Electronics and Information Technology in Parliament in 2019. However, Mehta highlighted a recent statement made by Minister of Railways, Communications and Electronics & Information Technology of India on the floor of the Parliament clarifying the government's stand.

A battery of senior advocates -- Kapil Sibal, Rakesh Dwivedi, Dinesh Dwivedi, Shyam Divan and Meenakshi Arora --representing various petitioners objected to the Centre's stand on the matter.

Sibal, representing veteran journalist N. Ram, said the government should clarify whether it used Pegasus or not? Sibal added that it is unbelievable that the government said it would not tell the court about the use of spyware.

"We thought government will file a counter affidavit. We are considering some interim order or some other order, we have to pass," the bench noted during the hearing.

Divan contended that a detailed affidavit should be filed at the level of cabinet secretary. He further added that the government should be concerned if an external agency used the spyware and if it were a government agency, then it was absolutely unconstitutional.

Senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi questioned the credibility of the expert panel formed by the government to examine the issue.

Mehta submitted, "Nobody is denying or disputing. There are sensitive issues involved. We must get to the core issue. Let the expert panel go into it."

The Chief Justice clarified that the court is also not keen on government disclosing any information which compromises the national security. The bench noted that if government were to file an affidavit, then it would have known "where do we stand on the subject".

Senior advocate Colin Gonsalves said a retired or sitting judge of the Supreme Court should head the probe, and the government, which is a wrongdoer, cannot be relied upon with the investigation.


More News
Taliban admire Imran Khan's efforts for Afghanistan
36 minutes ago
TRS, Congress workers clash at Revanth Reddy's residence
1 hour ago
Lakshmi Manchu had a blast hosting SIIMA awards
1 hour ago
SC collegium recommends 13 Chief Justices for various HCs
1 hour ago
Apple iOS 15 is now available to download
1 hour ago
YS Sharmila detained during weekly fast over unemployment
2 hours ago
Telangana man who built KCR temple puts it on sale
2 hours ago
In a first, MHA approves trial for shock batons for CAPF
2 hours ago
Musk mocks Biden for not appreciating SpaceX's historic civilian flight
2 hours ago
Taliban names remaining Ministers in caretaker govt
2 hours ago
Gautam Adani says on track to be the world's largest renewable generating company
3 hours ago
TSRTC restores 100 per cent services in Greater Hyderabad
3 hours ago
Amazon pays Rs 8,546 crore as legal fees in India to remain operational
4 hours ago
'It was pre-planned': Payal Ghosh on suspected 'acid attack'
4 hours ago
Armaan Malik on winning SIIMA award: 'Butta Bomma' one of my most memorable songs
5 hours ago
Myth or Fact: Exercise must be avoided after a heart attack
6 hours ago
At 26,115 new Covid cases, India sees dip in infections
6 hours ago
Apple hits record pre-orders in India with iPhone 13
7 hours ago
Sleep apnea affects 40L people in India
8 hours ago
Google Pixel 6 Pro specifications leaked ahead of launch
8 hours ago
Covid, climate crisis, Afghanistan to dominate UNGA
9 hours ago
US to ease travel curbs for fully vaccinated foreign visitors
10 hours ago
Refugees may pose Pakistan's biggest problem
11 hours ago
US Covid-19 fatalities surpass 1918 flu estimates
11 hours ago
Airport-like facilities for passengers at New Delhi rly station
11 hours ago
Rajiv assassination case: OPS seeks Stalin's intervention for release of life convicts
19 hours ago
IPL 2021: Kolkata Knight Riders thrash Royal Challengers Bangalore by nine wickets
20 hours ago
A greater India is visibly an India for Indians: Gautam Adani
20 hours ago
Amid global rout Sensex plunges over 500 points (Roundup)
20 hours ago
'Pawsome wedding': Acid and Jhanvi 'tie knot' at plush resort
20 hours ago