Pakistan's 'false' claims during Operation Sindoor fail scrutiny: Top US warfare expert

InternationalIANS
Advertisement
Washington, May 6 : India's Operation Sindoor, launched after the heinous terror attack that took place in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam on April 22 last year and witnessed Pakistan-backed terrorists gunning down 26 innocent tourists after identifying their religion, set in motion a sequence in which the Pakistan Air Force was increasingly outmatched. This included the establishment of air superiority over key sectors of Pakistani airspace and precision strikes across operational depth, a report said on Wednesday.

Writing for American online platform 'Substack', John Spencer, the Executive Director at the US-based Urban Warfare Institute, notes that even a year after the opening strikes of Operation Sindoor on May 7, 2025, the narrative of downed Indian aircraft and early Pakistani achievements continues to circulate. He added that in India–Pakistan clashes, the narrative has often followed a predictable pattern, with Pakistan rapidly shaping the information space through exaggerated or unverified claims across international media.

“The 88-hour air campaign from May 7 to 10, 2025, initially appeared to fit that pattern. Early reporting focused heavily on claims of Indian aircraft losses, and much of the Western coverage framed the Pakistan Air Force as having achieved a disproportionate success. That narrative did not withstand scrutiny,” the expert stated.

Citing a report released on January 15 by the Centre d’Histoire et de Prospective Militaires in Switzerland, Spencer said that the analysis reconstructs the conflict based on operational data rather than early narratives.

"Authored by military historian Adrien Fontanellaz and reviewed by a panel led by retired Swiss Air Force Major General Claude Meier, the study tracks the sequence of events across the four days of fighting. It shows that early aircraft losses, which dominated international coverage, were only one part of a larger campaign that unfolded very differently over time and ended with the Pakistan Air Force outmatched, India establishing air superiority over significant portions of Pakistani airspace, and conducting precision strikes across the depth of Pakistan,” he detailed.

Spencer emphasised that in retaliation for the April 22 terrorist attacks in Pahalgam, India struck nine terrorist sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir on May 7. Although Pakistan responded quickly, he said, the Indian Air Force had established air superiority over key sectors of Pakistani airspace, and the Pakistan Air Force became increasingly unsustainable after the opening night.

“That outcome was not the result of a single strike or isolated engagement. It emerged from a deliberate suppression and destruction of enemy air defences campaign conducted over multiple days that degraded Pakistan’s ability to see, coordinate, and respond,” he stated.

According to the expert, the analysis delivers India external validation, something its government rarely emphasises publicly - indicating that the objectives of Operation Sindoor were not only achieved but likely exceeded expectations.

“Whether India should have extended the campaign beyond 88 hours remains open for debate. Why Pakistan sought a ceasefire is clear. It did so after losing the ability to continue the fight on terms that could change the outcome,” Spencer stressed.

Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

John SpencerOperation SindoorIndia-Pakistan conflictPakistan Air ForceIndian Air Forceair superiorityPahalgam attackUrban Warfare InstituteAdrien FontanellazClaude Meier

More News

‘Hoping he has 3-4 more years,’ says Faf du Plessis on Virat Kohli’s IPL playing future

16 Nov, 17:09

Telangana BJP lodges complaint with FRRO against foreign delegates at Bharat Summit

16 Nov, 17:07

Kulgam attack: Two LeT terrorists, including Latief Bhat, killed in encounter

16 Nov, 17:06

Members of Indian community extend warm welcome to PM Modi in Manila

16 Nov, 17:05

BCCI congratulates Jay Shah on being reelected as ICC

16 Nov, 17:04

Sensex jumps over 500 points as bank, FMCG stocks shine

16 Nov, 16:03

Patidar’s unbeaten 135 powers MP to 131-run win; Uttarakhand, J&K and UP also register victories

16 Nov, 15:49

PM Modi arrives in Manila to attend ASEAN-India Summit and East Asia Summit

16 Nov, 15:32

Salman Khan shot in freezing water for 6 hours, ate food in wet clothes, says ‘Maatrubhumi’ director

16 Nov, 15:30

Encounter breaks out between security forces and terrorists in J&K’s Kulgam

16 Nov, 15:29

SC suspends sentence, grants bail to two convicts in Bilkis Bano gang-rape case

16 Nov, 15:14

Sachin plays gully cricket with UK's Prince William and Princess Kate

16 Nov, 15:13

BLA sharpens military strategy, appoints ex-Pakistan Army Captain as chief

16 Nov, 14:49

Sachin backs Jay Shah’s vision for cricket’s growth, wishes him success for second term as ICC Chair

16 Nov, 14:18

Trump ‘very positive’ on long-term friendship between India and US: IBM CEO

16 Nov, 14:09

Rahul, Kharge hold meeting with UP Cong leaders to discuss 2027 poll preparations

16 Nov, 14:02

Sensex may hit 95,000 by end of 2027 as analysts back India's re-rating

16 Nov, 13:50

There's pressure but we handled it well: Kavya Patel after India's U19 Asia Cup title triumph

16 Nov, 13:46

'Trust in your leadership speaks for itself': Gambhir leads cricket fraternity's wishes for Jay Shah

16 Nov, 12:45

India ready to play a bigger role on global AI stage: IBM’s Arvind Krishna

16 Nov, 12:34
..More News