Calcutta HC rejects Trinamool plea against ECI directive on central staff for counting duty

NationalIANS
Advertisement
Kolkata, April 30 : The Calcutta High Court on Thursday dismissed a writ petition filed by the Trinamool Congress challenging the Election Commission of India’s (ECI) directive to appoint Central government and Central Public Sector Undertaking (PSU) employees as counting supervisors and assistants for the 2026 West Bengal Assembly elections.

A single-judge bench of Justice Krishna Rao, which had reserved its order earlier in the day after hearing arguments from both sides, pronounced the verdict in the evening, rejecting the petition in its entirety.

“It is the prerogative of the Election Commission of India to appoint counting supervisors and counting assistants either from the state government or the Central government. This Court does not find any illegality in appointing counting supervisors and counting assistants from Central government/Central PSU employees instead of state government employees,” the court observed.

The High Court further noted that the impugned communication issued by the Additional Chief Electoral Officer, West Bengal, was aimed at ensuring “transparency, integrity and orderly conduct of counting proceedings” and formed part of the ongoing electoral process.

The bench observed that Clause 15.7.9 of the Handbook for Returning Officers permits counting supervisors and assistants to be appointed from either Central or state government officials or comparable undertakings. The court ruled that the ECI’s decision to prefer Central government/Central PSU employees was well within its authority.

Addressing the Trinamool Congress’ primary contention that Central government employees, being under the administrative control of the BJP-led Union government, could favour the principal opposition party in the state, the court held that such apprehension was not sustainable.

It pointed out that micro-observers, who are invariably drawn from Central government/Central PSU employees, would also be present at every counting table, along with counting agents of candidates and other officials, thereby ensuring adequate checks and balances.

The court further observed that if any irregularity or favouritism occurs during the counting process, the Trinamool Congress retains the right to challenge it through an election petition after the declaration of results.

Citing Section 100 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, the judgment stated: “If the petitioner proves that the Central Government/Central PSU employees appointed as counting supervisors and counting assistants helped the opponent by manipulating votes during counting, the petitioner has the liberty to raise all such grounds in an election petition.”

The writ petition had challenged a communication issued by the Additional Chief Electoral Officer, West Bengal, which required that “at least one among the counting supervisor and counting assistant at each counting table shall be a Central Government/Central PSU employee.”

Senior Advocate Kalyan Bandopadhyay, appearing for the petitioner, argued that the impugned directive lacked jurisdiction and deviated from the Election Commission’s own handbook, which does not mandate Central government personnel for such roles.

It was further contended that while micro-observers are required to be Central government/PSU employees, extending this requirement to counting supervisors and assistants was arbitrary and specific to West Bengal.
Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

Calcutta High CourtTrinamool CongressECICentral Public Sector

More News

Telangana: All-India Police Band competition begins in Hyderabad

16 Nov, 19:00

FM Sitharaman chairs 2nd pre-Budget consultation with leading agriculture, rural development experts

16 Nov, 18:58

Democracy under threat in Andhra Pradesh: YSRCP

16 Nov, 18:55

Indian diaspora in Manila hails PM Modi’s Philippines visit

16 Nov, 18:52

Another Italian Senator condemns Filibeck's remarks on Indian democracy

16 Nov, 18:49

‘Hoping he has 3-4 more years,’ says Faf du Plessis on Virat Kohli’s IPL playing future

16 Nov, 17:09

Telangana BJP lodges complaint with FRRO against foreign delegates at Bharat Summit

16 Nov, 17:07

Kulgam attack: Two LeT terrorists, including Latief Bhat, killed in encounter

16 Nov, 17:06

Members of Indian community extend warm welcome to PM Modi in Manila

16 Nov, 17:05

BCCI congratulates Jay Shah on being reelected as ICC

16 Nov, 17:04

Sensex jumps over 500 points as bank, FMCG stocks shine

16 Nov, 16:03

Patidar’s unbeaten 135 powers MP to 131-run win; Uttarakhand, J&K and UP also register victories

16 Nov, 15:49

PM Modi arrives in Manila to attend ASEAN-India Summit and East Asia Summit

16 Nov, 15:32

Salman Khan shot in freezing water for 6 hours, ate food in wet clothes, says ‘Maatrubhumi’ director

16 Nov, 15:30

Encounter breaks out between security forces and terrorists in J&K’s Kulgam

16 Nov, 15:29

SC suspends sentence, grants bail to two convicts in Bilkis Bano gang-rape case

16 Nov, 15:14

Sachin plays gully cricket with UK's Prince William and Princess Kate

16 Nov, 15:13

BLA sharpens military strategy, appoints ex-Pakistan Army Captain as chief

16 Nov, 14:49

Sachin backs Jay Shah’s vision for cricket’s growth, wishes him success for second term as ICC Chair

16 Nov, 14:18

Trump ‘very positive’ on long-term friendship between India and US: IBM CEO

16 Nov, 14:09
..More News