SC declines fresh guidelines on hate speech, says existing criminal law framework adequate

NationalIANS
Advertisement
New Delhi, April 29 : The Supreme Court on Wednesday declined to issue any additional directions or frame fresh guidelines to curb hate speech across the country, holding that the existing criminal law framework is adequate to address such offences.

A Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta dismissed a batch of petitions seeking further judicial intervention against communal hate speeches, including matters arising from incidents such as alleged “Corona Jihad” campaigns, “UPSC Jihad” broadcasts, and inflammatory speeches delivered at various religious gatherings.

The Justice Nath-led Bench held that the creation of criminal offences and the prescription of punishments fall exclusively within the legislative domain, and Constitutional courts cannot compel Parliament or state legislatures to enact new laws.

“While constitutional courts may interpret the law and issue directions to secure the enforcement of fundamental rights, they cannot legislate or compel legislation,” the top court observed, adding that at best, courts may draw attention to the need for reform, while the decision to legislate remains with Parliament and state legislatures.

Rejecting the argument that hate speech remains insufficiently addressed under current laws, the Justice Nath-led Bench said that provisions under substantive criminal law, including the Indian Penal Code, adequately cover acts promoting enmity, outraging religious sentiments, and disturbing public tranquillity.

“The field is therefore not unoccupied,” it said, stressing that the real concern lies in effective enforcement rather than any legislative vacuum.

Listing the remedies already available under the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, the Supreme Court reiterated that registration of an FIR upon disclosure of a cognisable offence is mandatory.

It said that in cases where police fail to register FIRs, aggrieved persons can approach the Superintendent of Police under Section 154(3) CrPC or Section 173(4) BNSS, and thereafter seek recourse before the jurisdictional magistrate under Section 156(3) CrPC or Section 175 BNSS, or proceed through a private complaint.

While refusing to pass new directions, the Justice Nath-led Bench acknowledged the gravity of the issue, observing that hate speech and rumour mongering directly impact fraternity, dignity, and constitutional order.

“We deem it appropriate to observe that issues relating to hate speech and rumour mongering bear directly upon the preservation of fraternity, dignity and constitutional order,” the Supreme Court said.

It added that the Union and state governments remain free to consider whether evolving societal challenges require additional legislative interventions, including amendments suggested in the Law Commission’s 267th Report of 2017.

The judgment was delivered in petitions tracing back to 2020, when multiple pleas were filed alleging the spread of communal narratives through broadcast media, social media platforms, and public religious assemblies.

Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

Supreme Courthate speechfresh guidelinescriminal law framework

More News

Telangana: All-India Police Band competition begins in Hyderabad

16 Nov, 19:00

FM Sitharaman chairs 2nd pre-Budget consultation with leading agriculture, rural development experts

16 Nov, 18:58

Democracy under threat in Andhra Pradesh: YSRCP

16 Nov, 18:55

Indian diaspora in Manila hails PM Modi’s Philippines visit

16 Nov, 18:52

Another Italian Senator condemns Filibeck's remarks on Indian democracy

16 Nov, 18:49

‘Hoping he has 3-4 more years,’ says Faf du Plessis on Virat Kohli’s IPL playing future

16 Nov, 17:09

Telangana BJP lodges complaint with FRRO against foreign delegates at Bharat Summit

16 Nov, 17:07

Kulgam attack: Two LeT terrorists, including Latief Bhat, killed in encounter

16 Nov, 17:06

Members of Indian community extend warm welcome to PM Modi in Manila

16 Nov, 17:05

BCCI congratulates Jay Shah on being reelected as ICC

16 Nov, 17:04

Sensex jumps over 500 points as bank, FMCG stocks shine

16 Nov, 16:03

Patidar’s unbeaten 135 powers MP to 131-run win; Uttarakhand, J&K and UP also register victories

16 Nov, 15:49

PM Modi arrives in Manila to attend ASEAN-India Summit and East Asia Summit

16 Nov, 15:32

Salman Khan shot in freezing water for 6 hours, ate food in wet clothes, says ‘Maatrubhumi’ director

16 Nov, 15:30

Encounter breaks out between security forces and terrorists in J&K’s Kulgam

16 Nov, 15:29

SC suspends sentence, grants bail to two convicts in Bilkis Bano gang-rape case

16 Nov, 15:14

Sachin plays gully cricket with UK's Prince William and Princess Kate

16 Nov, 15:13

BLA sharpens military strategy, appoints ex-Pakistan Army Captain as chief

16 Nov, 14:49

Sachin backs Jay Shah’s vision for cricket’s growth, wishes him success for second term as ICC Chair

16 Nov, 14:18

Trump ‘very positive’ on long-term friendship between India and US: IBM CEO

16 Nov, 14:09
..More News