SC to continue hearing on petition challenging Sonam Wangchuk's detention

NationalIANS
Advertisement
New Delhi, Feb 5 : The Supreme Court will continue to hear the government's arguments in the petition filed against the detention of Ladakh-based social activist Sonam Wangchuk under the National Security Act (NSA).

Earlier on Wednesday, the apex court orally asked the Centre to reconsider the continued preventive detention of Sonam Wangchuk under the NSA.

A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and P.B. Varale was hearing a habeas corpus petition filed by Wangchuk's wife, Dr Gitanjali Angmo, which termed his detention "illegal" and an "arbitrary exercise violating his fundamental rights".

During the hearing, the Justice Aravind Kumar-led bench observed that Wangchuk had been in custody since September 26, 2025, and that the medical reports placed before the apex court indicated his health was "certainly not very good".

It was suggested to Additional Solicitor General (ASG) K.M. Nataraj that the government should "give it a thought" as to whether there was a possibility of rethinking the continuation of Wangchuk's detention.

In response, ASG Nataraj assured the Supreme Court that he would seek instructions from the authorities.

Defending the detention, he argued that the NSA is a special law enacted for preventive purposes.

"The NSA is meant to prevent a person from acting in a manner prejudicial to public order or the security of the state. Preventive detention is not punishment. It is based on the discretion of the detaining authority," he told the apex court, adding that the District Magistrate had passed the order after objectively assessing the materials placed before him.

ASG Natraj submitted that Wangchuk's speech, delivered on September 24, 2025, was provocative in nature and triggered violent protests in Leh, resulting in four deaths and injuries to 161 people. He further contended that while Wangchuk had challenged the original detention order, he had not assailed subsequent orders.

However, the Justice Aravind Kumar-led Bench indicated that if the very foundation of the detention order was found to be legally deficient, including on grounds of non-application of mind, subsequent approvals would not independently sustain it.

The Supreme Court remarked that if the detention order is quashed, all subsequent actions would stand invalidated. In an earlier hearing, the bench noted Wangchuk's health concerns and ordered a specialist from a government hospital to examine him, with the medical report submitted in a sealed cover.
Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

Sonam WangchukSupreme CourtNational Security ActNSAPreventive DetentionJustice Aravind KumarDr Gitanjali AngmoLadakhHabeas Corpus

More News

‘Akvan’ set to intensify into severe cyclone by evening; Andhra CM takes stock of situation

17 Nov, 11:24

Six Pakistani soldiers killed in 4 drone Ops across Balochistan: BLA

17 Nov, 11:09

13 killed in three separate road accidents in Uttarakhand; CM Dhami expresses grief

17 Nov, 11:03

Rupee gains 31 paise against US dollar amid falling crude oil prices

17 Nov, 10:41

Gas leak from ONGC well in Andhra’s Konaseema district triggers panic

17 Nov, 10:39

'Seven batters, four pacers': Gill reveals India's combinations for Test series opener vs NZ

17 Nov, 10:35

Different religions don't have equal place in American identity: US preacher

17 Nov, 10:20

Two public safety officers shot in New York; gunman found dead

17 Nov, 10:11

Former India Caucus co-chair Jim McDermott dies at 89

17 Nov, 10:10

Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East amid Iran tensions

17 Nov, 10:09

Vance says Trump will avoid ‘forever war’ in Iran

17 Nov, 10:08

US court strikes down fixed stay rule for international students, exchange visitors

17 Nov, 10:07

Iran says another 'violating' oiler caught fire in Hormuz, denies air defence activity in central province

17 Nov, 10:05

US touts truck-driver crackdown as safety gain

17 Nov, 09:50

2027 UP polls: SP, Cong to hold seat-sharing negotiations in Delhi today

17 Nov, 09:49

Indian American Congressman seeks $1,700 Iran war refund for families

17 Nov, 08:59

US Senate bill seeks to withhold $33 million Pakistan aid until Shakil Afridi's release

17 Nov, 08:58

PM Modi to attend ASEAN-India, East Asia summits in Manila today

17 Nov, 08:56

California's Hindu temple reports new break-in

17 Nov, 08:56

K’taka Minister directs officials to initiate legal action against MLA over ‘hate speech’ row

17 Nov, 08:55
..More News