US lawmakers warn 'public charge' rule risks H-1B green cards

InternationalIANS
Advertisement
Washington, Dec 24, : A group of 127 US lawmakers has urged the Trump Administration to withdraw its proposed overhaul of the "public charge" rule, asserting that this would inject uncertainty into the legal immigration system, particularly for those families who are moving from H-1B visas to Green Cards.

As many as 110 Congressmen and 17 Senators, in a letter, called on the Department of Homeland Security to abandon the proposal and retain the existing 2022 public charge regulations, arguing that the current framework provides clarity, fairness, and consistency for immigrant families and adjudicators.

"The proposed public charge rule will lead to mass uncertainty, disparate and arbitrary outcomes for individuals applying for permanent status or admission into our country, and undue harm to US citizens," the lawmakers said in their letter dated December 19, a copy of which was released on Tuesday.

The letter was led in the House by Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus Chair Grace Meng, Congressional Hispanic Caucus Chair Adriano Espaillat, Democratic Women's Caucus Chair Teresa Leger Fernandez, Congressional Black Caucus Chair Yvette Clarke, and Rep. Robert Menendez, and in the Senate by Senators Mazie Hirono, Alex Padilla, and Cory Booker.

Three Indian American Congressmen, Raja Krishnamoorthi, Ro Khanna, and Pramila Jayapal, signed the letter.

The Trump administration proposal would rescind the clear 2022 public charge regulations and replace them with what lawmakers described as vague and undefined standards, leaving future determinations to shifting "policy and interpretive tools".

The letter warns that such an approach would invite arbitrary decision-making, create fear among immigrant families, and erode trust in the legal immigration system.

In the letter, the lawmakers said that by discarding the existing framework without establishing a lawful replacement, the proposal would create immediate uncertainty for families seeking adjustment of status, including refugees, survivors of domestic violence or trafficking, and children who have been abused, neglected, or abandoned -- groups Congress has long sought to shield from punitive public charge treatment.

"The chilling effects triggered by expansions of public charge interpretation are well-documented and severe," the lawmakers wrote. Research shows that confusion around past public charge restrictions led large numbers of eligible immigrant families, including those with US citizen children, to forgo health insurance, nutrition supports, and early childhood programs vital to healthy development, they said.

The letter argues that the proposal contradicts long-standing interpretations of the Immigration and Nationality Act and risks discriminatory and uneven application of the law. Lawmakers also raised concerns that DHS could rely on undefined or potentially unlawful data-sharing practices with other government agencies, further undermining transparency and accountability in immigration adjudications.

Members warned that fear-driven policies would not only harm immigrant households but also shift costs to state and local governments. Reduced participation in preventive healthcare and nutrition programs, they said, would likely increase uncompensated emergency care, worsen child health outcomes, and strain public health systems.

The concerns outlined in the letter have particular resonance for employment-based immigrants who face lengthy waits for permanent residency, a group dominated by Indian nationals navigating the H-1B-to-green-card process.

For Indian nationals, who account for the largest share of employment-based green card backlogs, the warning about "mass uncertainty" is especially significant. Many Indian professionals remain on H-1B or other temporary visas for extended periods -- often well over a decade -- while waiting for permanent residency, raising US-citizen children along the way.

Lawmakers said ambiguity over how DHS might assess past or lawful use of benefits could discourage families from seeking assistance they are legally entitled to receive.
Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

Trump Administrationpublic charge ruleH-1B visaGreen CardUS lawmakersDepartment of Homeland SecurityimmigrationIndian nationalsemployment-based green card

More News

Telangana’s 4,000 MW Yadadri plant to achieve full capacity soon

17 Nov, 19:01

Reports of unwanted Instagram recommendations in India halved over past year: Meta

17 Nov, 19:00

Trump watches as PM Modi picks up Indian flag marker from floor, video goes viral

17 Nov, 18:58

Rajinikanth's daughter Soundarya shares pictures of their family getaway in Greece; says 'What amazing memories we’ve made in Athens!'

17 Nov, 18:56

When Jackie Shroff gave 10x returns to Archana Puran Singh on pending principal amount from struggling days

17 Nov, 18:54

'There was no one like Dhoni, and can't see anyone in next 10 years either': Coach MP Singh

17 Nov, 18:53

Dulquer Salmaan's 'Aakasamlo Oka Tara' cleared for release with U/A certificate

17 Nov, 18:52

Gas leak from ONGC well in Andhra brought under control

17 Nov, 18:50

‘Learned the meaning of simplicity…’: Ruturaj Gaikwad’s heartfelt tribute to Dhoni

17 Nov, 18:49

Dhanush, Mammootty-starrer 'Om' cleared for release with U/A certificate!

17 Nov, 18:47

Sri Lanka lose 15 WTC points, Pakistan docked five for slow over-rate during Rawalpindi Test

17 Nov, 18:46

'IPL will not be the same': Cricket fraternity pays emotional tribute to MS Dhoni after retirement

17 Nov, 18:44

Rahul Gandhi responds to backlash over 'lap' remark, shares temple sculpture

17 Nov, 18:43

PM Modi is 'a very tough man': Trump after meeting Quad counterparts

17 Nov, 17:06

Drug cartels turn to private players, DIY videos to evade crackdown; agencies flag new trend

17 Nov, 17:05

Gurnoor Brar reprimanded for Code of Conduct breach, handed one demerit point

17 Nov, 17:03

Why did Telangana find no mention in Sonia Gandhi’s book: BRS

17 Nov, 17:02

MS Dhoni’s IPL legacy: Five titles, 5,439 runs and several records

17 Nov, 16:57

Nifty hits 9-month high, Bank Nifty scales record peak as market rally extends

17 Nov, 16:00

Dhoni quietly said, ‘Maybe you should add my name' in release list, reveals CSK owner Rupa Gurunath

17 Nov, 15:46
..More News