'Be alive to ground realities': SC refuse to entertain PIL challenged bottled water standards

NationalIANS
Advertisement
New Delhi, Dec 18 : The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to entertain a public interest litigation (PIL) challenging India's existing quality standards for bottled drinking water and plastic packaging.

A bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi remarked that the plea reflected a disconnect from the country’s ground realities.

The PIL questioned the standards prescribed by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) and the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) for permissible levels of antimony and DEHP (Di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate) in packaged drinking water and plastic bottles.

During the hearing, the CJI Surya Kant-led Bench remarked on the petitioner’s reliance on foreign standards and guidelines.

"With the situation we face, do you (the petitioner) think we can implement US guidelines, etc. Be alive to ground realities. You are citing Australian and Saudi Arabian guidelines. This is all just talking in the air," the apex court observed, adding that India cannot at this stage adopt benchmarks followed in developed countries.

"If the petitioner would have pushed for drinking water supply in villages which do not have access to any, we can understand. But what description should be on water bottles, etc., is just luxury litigation," the bench said.

The Supreme Court refused to entertain the petition but granted liberty to the petitioner to submit a representation to the government authorities.

"Submit a representation to the authorities. We are sure it will be considered," the bench said.

The petition, filed under Article 32 of the Constitution through advocate Shrishti Agnihotri, had sought quashing of FSSAI and BIS notifications prescribing permissible limits of antimony and DEHP in drinking water and plastic packaging, alleging that the standards were "ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution" and contrary to the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006.

As per the PIL, India, being a signatory to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, is obligated to ensure that international norms relating to health and safe drinking water are implemented through domestic law.

The petitioner argued that Indian standards "allow a higher amount of antimony and DEHP to be present in drinking water, as compared to the safe permissible amount set by the World Health Organisation and in other countries”.

The plea further alleged that FSSAI failed to discharge its statutory duty under Section 18 of the FSSAI Act, 2006, which mandates that international standards be taken into account while framing regulations and that an "open and transparent public consultation" be conducted during the preparation or revision of standards.

Contending that higher exposure to antimony and DEHP poses serious health risks, including cardiovascular, respiratory and organ-related disorders, the petitioner claimed that the existing standards violate the right to health and the right to clean drinking water under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

Surya KantSupreme Court of IndiaPILbottled water standardsFSSAIBISdrinking water qualityShrishti AgnihotriJustice Joymalya Bagchi

More News

Telangana’s 4,000 MW Yadadri plant to achieve full capacity soon

17 Nov, 19:01

Reports of unwanted Instagram recommendations in India halved over past year: Meta

17 Nov, 19:00

Trump watches as PM Modi picks up Indian flag marker from floor, video goes viral

17 Nov, 18:58

Rajinikanth's daughter Soundarya shares pictures of their family getaway in Greece; says 'What amazing memories we’ve made in Athens!'

17 Nov, 18:56

When Jackie Shroff gave 10x returns to Archana Puran Singh on pending principal amount from struggling days

17 Nov, 18:54

'There was no one like Dhoni, and can't see anyone in next 10 years either': Coach MP Singh

17 Nov, 18:53

Dulquer Salmaan's 'Aakasamlo Oka Tara' cleared for release with U/A certificate

17 Nov, 18:52

Gas leak from ONGC well in Andhra brought under control

17 Nov, 18:50

‘Learned the meaning of simplicity…’: Ruturaj Gaikwad’s heartfelt tribute to Dhoni

17 Nov, 18:49

Dhanush, Mammootty-starrer 'Om' cleared for release with U/A certificate!

17 Nov, 18:47

Sri Lanka lose 15 WTC points, Pakistan docked five for slow over-rate during Rawalpindi Test

17 Nov, 18:46

'IPL will not be the same': Cricket fraternity pays emotional tribute to MS Dhoni after retirement

17 Nov, 18:44

Rahul Gandhi responds to backlash over 'lap' remark, shares temple sculpture

17 Nov, 18:43

PM Modi is 'a very tough man': Trump after meeting Quad counterparts

17 Nov, 17:06

Drug cartels turn to private players, DIY videos to evade crackdown; agencies flag new trend

17 Nov, 17:05

Gurnoor Brar reprimanded for Code of Conduct breach, handed one demerit point

17 Nov, 17:03

Why did Telangana find no mention in Sonia Gandhi’s book: BRS

17 Nov, 17:02

MS Dhoni’s IPL legacy: Five titles, 5,439 runs and several records

17 Nov, 16:57

Nifty hits 9-month high, Bank Nifty scales record peak as market rally extends

17 Nov, 16:00

Dhoni quietly said, ‘Maybe you should add my name' in release list, reveals CSK owner Rupa Gurunath

17 Nov, 15:46
..More News