RS Chairman Radhakrishnan cautions members on limits of debate over election reforms

NationalIANS
Advertisement
New Delhi, Dec 11 : Ahead of a scheduled discussion in the Rajya Sabha, Chairman C.P. Radhakrishnan reminded members of the constitutional and procedural boundaries governing parliamentary debate, particularly when it touches upon institutions of high authority.

He underscored that the Election Commission of India (ECI) is an autonomous constitutional body under Article 324 of the Constitution, and its day-to-day functioning does not fall under the direct purview of the Government of India.

Chairman Radhakrishnan referred to Rule 238 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Council of States, which prohibits members from reflecting upon the conduct of persons in high authority unless the discussion is based on a substantive motion framed in proper terms.

He further noted that matters relating to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in various states are currently sub judice before the Supreme Court, and therefore cannot be debated in the House.

“Members must refrain from making submissions that contravene these provisions. Anything said in violation will not form part of the record,” he cautioned.

The Chair’s intervention came as members prepared to take part in a politically charged discussion.

He repeatedly urged patience, asking members to allow the proceedings to begin in order.

In response, Tiruchi Shiva questioned the interpretation of the rules. The members recalled a precedent set by a former Chairman, Jagdish Dhankhar, who had once ruled that “anything under the sky can be discussed in the House”. They argued that unless the Chair explicitly overruled that precedent, it remained valid, and therefore restrictions on debate were “null and void”.

The exchange highlighted the tension between procedural safeguards and the expansive nature of parliamentary debate.

While the Chair insisted on adherence to constitutional and judicial boundaries, “I will go by the rule in the book,” the chairman said and initiated the debate on election reforms.

Advertisement

Note: The content of this article is sourced from a news agency and has not been edited by the ap7am team.

C.P. RadhakrishnanRajya SabhaElection Commission of Indiaelection reformsparliamentary debateRule 238sub judiceJagdish DhankharTiruchi Shivaconstitutional boundaries

More News

IPL 2027: All ten teams' retained players list, slots available details ahead of mini-auction

17 Nov, 21:29

Dhoni's presence as mentor will help next generation of CSK players: Rashid Latif

17 Nov, 21:27

IPL 2027: Starc, Head, Pathirana among big names out as all franchises release players

17 Nov, 21:25

'Dhoni was mentoring players even as captain, so it's nothing new for him,' says Irfan Pathan

17 Nov, 21:23

'Mai har ek pal ka shayar hu': MS Dhoni shares heartfelt video as 'fans proved me wrong'

17 Nov, 21:21

Andhra Pradesh CM Chandrababu urges Centre to provide funds for cyclone relief

17 Nov, 21:20

Telangana’s 4,000 MW Yadadri plant to achieve full capacity soon

17 Nov, 19:01

Reports of unwanted Instagram recommendations in India halved over past year: Meta

17 Nov, 19:00

Trump watches as PM Modi picks up Indian flag marker from floor, video goes viral

17 Nov, 18:58

Rajinikanth's daughter Soundarya shares pictures of their family getaway in Greece; says 'What amazing memories we’ve made in Athens!'

17 Nov, 18:56

When Jackie Shroff gave 10x returns to Archana Puran Singh on pending principal amount from struggling days

17 Nov, 18:54

'There was no one like Dhoni, and can't see anyone in next 10 years either': Coach MP Singh

17 Nov, 18:53

Dulquer Salmaan's 'Aakasamlo Oka Tara' cleared for release with U/A certificate

17 Nov, 18:52

Gas leak from ONGC well in Andhra brought under control

17 Nov, 18:50

‘Learned the meaning of simplicity…’: Ruturaj Gaikwad’s heartfelt tribute to Dhoni

17 Nov, 18:49

Dhanush, Mammootty-starrer 'Om' cleared for release with U/A certificate!

17 Nov, 18:47

Sri Lanka lose 15 WTC points, Pakistan docked five for slow over-rate during Rawalpindi Test

17 Nov, 18:46

'IPL will not be the same': Cricket fraternity pays emotional tribute to MS Dhoni after retirement

17 Nov, 18:44

Rahul Gandhi responds to backlash over 'lap' remark, shares temple sculpture

17 Nov, 18:43

PM Modi is 'a very tough man': Trump after meeting Quad counterparts

17 Nov, 17:06
..More News